The Speculist: It's a New Phil, Week 39

logo.jpg

Live to see it.


« Meme Wars | Main | Skype Sucks »

It's a New Phil, Week 39

Back up a pound this week to 235, giving me a total weight loss of 62 pounds. After talking it over with the staff at Dr. Harris's office today, I have decided that -- after next week -- I'm going to start weighing in every other week rather than every week. I seem to be having one up week followed by one down week, so maybe this will show the progress is a smoother way.

But I'll keep updating this column every week, of course.

Stephen raises some interesting points about doctors now treating obesity as a disease, reated to this article in Wired:

My thought is that there is no down side to classifying any physical problem that medicine can actually help as a disease. Notice that qualification. When medicine couldn't treat certain problems (alcoholism, obesity, depression, and at present aging), it was not particularly helpful to think of those problems as diseases. Better to tell the sufferer to get some backbone and put down the bottle, drop the fork, and cheer up because we ain't getting any younger.

But to the extent that medicine can help a problem, what harm is there is classifying it as a disease?

I agree up to a point. If by treating it like a disease, we mean paying attention to it and constructively engaging patients to help them overcome it -- as my doctor has -- I'm all for it. I also don't have any objection pharmacalogical solutions, and when a reasonably safe and effective "fat pill" makes it to the market, I'll certainly consider it.

Where I draw the line is major surgery. I'm not saying that it isn't the right solution for some people, but I would personally rather be fat than have intestinal by-pass surgery. Whatever damage obesity may have done to my body, I would have a hard time believing that subjecting myself to that kind of trauma could help somehow.

(Continued / Comments after advertisement.)

It's a New Phil, Week 1

It's a New Phil, Week 2

It's a New Phil, Week 3

It's a New Phil, Week 4

It's a New Phil, Week 5

It's a New Phil, Week 6

It's a New Phil, Week 7

It's a New Phil, Week 8

It's a New Phil, Week 9

It's a New Phil, Week 10

It's a New Phil, Week 11

It's a New Phil, Week 12

It's a New Phil, week 13

It's a New Phil, Week 14

It's a New Phil, Week 15

It's a New Phil, Week 16

It's a New Phil, Week 17

It's a New Phil, Week 18

It's a New Phil, Week 19

It's a New Phil, Week 20

I was on vacation during week 21 and did not post an entry, but thanks for noticing the blank space!

It's a New Phil, Week 22

It's a New Phil, Week 23

It's a New Phil, Week 24

It's a New Phil, Week 25

It's a New Phil, Week 26

It's a New Phil, Week 27

It's a New Phil, Week 28

It's a New Phil, Week 29

It's a New Phil, Week 30

It's a New Phil, Week 31

It's a New Phil, Week 32

It's a New Phil, Week 33

It's a New Phil, Week 34

It's a New Phil, Week 35

It's a New Phil, Week 36

It's a New Phil, Week 37

It's a New Phil, Week 38

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)






Be a Speculist

Share your thoughts on the future with more than

70,000

Speculist readers. Write to us at:

speculist1@yahoo.com

(More details here.)



Blogroll



Categories

Powered by
Movable Type 3.2